Sports Photographers File New York Copyright Infringement Lawsuit Against the NFL and Others
In October, the National Football League (NFL) was hit with a copyright infringement lawsuit that was filed in New York by several freelance sports photographers. In Spinelli, et al. v. National Football League, et al. , seven photographers accused Getty Images and the Associated Press (AP) of providing their photos to the NFL without paying the appropriate royalties. According to the complaint, the NFL allegedly used its market power to obtain the images without charge from both Getty and the AP.
The photographers who filed the lawsuit claim their images are used by both Getty and the AP under a type of agreement that allows each of the photographers to retain control over image licensing. Despite that the agreements require Getty and the AP to track usage of each image and pay the photographers based on the frequency of each photo’s use, the NFL was allegedly allowed to use many images free of charge. The plaintiffs claim the NFL secured use of the images without compensating the photographers by threatening each image company that the other would be made the official and exclusive league image service.
According to the lawsuit, Getty, the AP, and the NFL infringed on the freelance photographers’ copyrights when the NFL was allowed to display numerous sports photos without payment to the plaintiffs. In addition, Getty and the AP are accused of breach of contract for allowing the alleged infringement. The NFL has responded by filing a motion to be dismissed from the case.
In its motion, the league claims the sports photographers’ real dispute is with the co-defendant image companies. The NFL argued that it did not infringe on the plaintiffs’ copyrights because the league obtained valid license to use the images at issue from Getty and the AP. The AP also sought dismissal of the case due to the purportedly broad rights the image company obtained through the photography agreements. Interestingly, Getty did not seek to have the case dismissed but instead filed a demand for arbitration pursuant to the terms of the photography contracts.
If you are facing a copyright or other intellectual property dispute, contact the knowledgeable New York City intellectual property lawyers at Korngut Paleudis LLC. Our experienced attorneys are available to help you analyze the key issues and develop a litigation strategy that best suits your business needs.
The hardworking lawyers at Korngut Paleudis LLC have more than 45 years of experience assisting clients who are located in New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut. To speak with a skilled advocate about your intellectual property or other business law claim, please contact Korngut Paleudis LLC through the law firm’s website or give us a call at (212) 949-0138 in New York City, (914) 220-8270 in White Plains, or (203) 355-3635 in Stamford, Connecticut.
Cracker Barrel Trademark Dispute Will Keep Restaurant Chain’s Products Off of Grocery Shelves in New Jersey and Elsewhere for Now, New York City Business Litigation Lawyer Blog, November 29, 2013
Decision in Apple v. Samsung Patent Dispute May Make it More Difficult for Companies to Obtain a Permanent Injunction in New York and Nationwide, New York City Business Litigation Lawyer Blog, November 21, 2013
Photo credit: mr_write, morgueFile